Sunday, March 16, 2014

Why Write?


Alfred Corn's latest thread on writing:

The USA is where writers on Facebook say, "I write for myself, recording what comes directly from the heart. I don't care about audience and never take other people's standards into account." But then, when a poem is accepted by a magazine or nominated for inclusion in the Pushcart annual, joyfully announce the fact, to a chorus of congratulations.

  • Carole Ann Borges The two are not mutually exclusive.
    1 hr · Like · 3
  • Alfred Corn How so, Carole Ann?
    1 hr · Like
  • Wendy Battin These USA comments indicate that I don't live here. That comes as no surprise. (I don't check my phone often enough, either. Sorry.)
    1 hr · Edited · Like · 2
  • Su Zi Well, we could call it philosophical inconsistency, or hypocrisy; we could claim it as defensive posturing that unveils itself; we could call it self effacing with a dessert of pride; we could be kind and celebrate the publication and ignore the self conscious statements that preceed it. Given the cultural celebration of the moronic without the joyous breath of oxy, and given the gulag-like attack on anthing thoughtful, I would tend toward the huzzah for publication in the spirit of unity
    1 hr · Like · 2
  • Bill Lantry Always disbelieve those who say they write for themselves. Never accept claims disregarding audience. I've always thought poets should be honest, but we tend to deceive ourselves first.
    1 hr · Like · 4
  • Alfred Corn I believe the poet who says s/he writes only for her/himself and is indifferent to audience, when they never enroll in a writing course and never seek to publish.
    1 hr · Unlike · 4
  • Wendy Battin I might write for myself insofar as I have to write, but that's because it's meant to read and to have its own life in the reader. Bill Knott is still too close to my thoughts now to see it otherwise. As for speaking the heart, that's not enough to make poetry without all of being and skill behind it. The language has the whole in it. Speak that.
    1 hr · Like · 3
  • Carolyn Holmes Gregory I have been a serious writer for many years with a number of major life interruptions that took place vis a vis deaths, other unexpected losses, times of poverty and the like. I have not ever written just for myself, only, and am more public now than ever as a vocal activist for change on many levels. I have a pen and a voice and so I use them!
    1 hr · Like · 3
  • Anna Husain Is there any particular reason for this? We write for ourselves, others, we are each autonomous as to how we come to writing and where it takes us, must there be one rule to rule us all, and the rest be damned, because they are seemingly insincere or "hypocritical" or not to our code of literary ethics? With my last breath, I vote for inclusion,...as to talent and worthiness, let fate and history sort out the rest.
    56 mins · Like · 3
  • Djelloul Marbrook I too am thinking of Knott’s astonishing interview. I discussed Friday evening with Gerard Malanga who remarked that Knott had really gotten the attention of which he claimed to have been deprived. I told Gerard I’m not so sure. I would have said, too, that Stanley Plumly’s attention came rather belatedly. I feel that Knott’s pain keeps eluding me, that I need to try harder to understand where he was coming from. It certainly was about belonging and unbelonging, issues that have vexed me. I think some of us instinctively unbelong for many different reasons, some of them so internalized as to be inaccessible. I’m really not prepared to make any judgments about why poets write or whether they entertain more ambition than they cop to. I suspect they follow their instincts for better and worse. And sometimes better or worse doesn’t emerge until long after they’ve left the stage, a stage that might well have eluded them in the first place. I remember a famous poet answering this question, What is the worst thing that ever happened to you as a poet? God, what a question! Perhaps I would have said most of the poems I write, but this guy quite marvelously said, Following Mark Strand at the podium.
    55 mins · Like · 4
  • Carole Ann Borges I think I write for myself, but not in the narrow context it seems to be used here. I mean that I am not overly concerned with pandering to what I think the magazines might like or to copying (with slight alteration of tints) someone else's poems beca...See More
    52 mins · Edited · Like · 3
  • Norman Finkelstein Publication – is the Auction
    Of the Mind of Man –
    53 mins · Like · 3
  • Djelloul Marbrook Bravo! Our culture is about auction.
    52 mins · Like · 2
  • Judith Barrington I have had many students who say this very thing and provoke a certain impatience in me. Not only are they enrolled in a writing class, eager for the other students (and me) to be their audience, but furthermore, the very act of writing implies communication with others or other. NO. They don't write as if it's a letter beginning, "Dear me, I'm about to tell you a story you already know..." They tell the story to some reader or other, whether they know it or not.
    48 mins · Like · 2
  • Jack Miller What exactly does "writing for yourself" mean? I write because I have to write, first, my journals as a thought process to carry out Socrates' "Know thyself"-- which I have kept irregularly since I was 18, which are an ever surprising source of revelation about my past selves. Then there are the articles, dissertation, reviews and the like I have published in relation to my education and my profession, but often for sheer enjoyment. These are often reactions I want to share. Finally there are my novel, short stories, and poems, which I have written because I wanted to create something out of my knowledge and experience that go beyond myself, but which I have never been willing to pursue publication with the determination it apparently takes to find the right place and to tailor the work to a particular journal or press. My journals, poems, and my fiction are not polished or "finished" in the sense of being edited and ready for specific publication. Eventually that might matter to me, but not now. Writing is its own reward, an intrinsic good giving me the joy of an aesthetic distance from, a unique perspective upon, myself and my experience of life, friends, lovers, nature, existence, and the state of the world.
    44 mins · Like · 2
  • Wendy Battin Djelloul, I don't find it hard to understand Knott. He struggled so long it was hard to get through, and those who can afford to be poets live a different life. I'm awed by the work he managed to leave us, always have been.
    44 mins · Like · 2
  • Carole Ann Borges I do sometimes tell students or people in workshops that there is the possibility of writing only for one's self, but that means their work very likely will never be up to publishing standards. Poetry writing is a skill like any other and needs to be studied and techniques need to be learned. It is a choice they have to make.. I have met adults who have many journals full of poems they have never sent out. Not everyone who sings in the shower needs to strive to be a famous singer. Not every student in a writing class really wants to be a successful writer.
  • Djelloul Marbrook Jack, I regard my poems as algorithms. I use them to figure out things I need to understand, to cope with conundrums, Gordian knots, so I understand very well your remarks.
    41 mins · Unlike · 2

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

High on the Mountain

Two visits to Lookout Mountain and Chattanooga in December and January were splendid: one with Joe, and one to receive a relaxing, soothing massage. Starr was the perfect hostess both visits. On both, we went to Talus and to Tupelo Honey. On both we listened to Radio Paradise and sat by a roaring fire in the fireplace. Here are some photos:

Trip One:















Joe Mydell and Sophie













Joe Mydell and Starr Tays
at Talus on the Mt.

 Art along the Chattanooga Riverfront







Trip Two:





Sunday, January 12, 2014

2014


Another year along Rte 66. Time to revisit the enchanted garden?

Zen Nights Dharma Days

Authored by: 
 Jack Miller

Zen. Sublimity. There are few words to conjure the world of Kalani Honua, a place of rhythms and life. Fortunate are the happy souls who come here, intermingle, and experience such contact with earth, air, volcanic fire, and water-- the ocean and the waterfalls, and the pools of clear healing water. People here connect to the land in a holistic way difficult to imagine on the mainland of the U.S. Everything flows in a harmony that resonates in those who live and work here.
It is easy to photograph the flowers, the pristine beaches, the steam from Kiluea, from Pele. It is easy to imagine, to recall, the joy of sitting in the swing pictured here, gazing at the ocean for whales, for the spume as they catch their breath, dolphins, black crabs scurrying over the black lava rocks. Life is exquisite here, like a rare orchid. The lizard on the sunny sill has found enlightenment.

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Winter Solstice 2013


Solstice Approaches...

2013 has been a year full of wonder and a year of transition. My two weeks of wandering throughout Japan in April, cherry blossoms in bloom, gave me a sense of Japanese culture from Shinto and Buddhism in Nara to gay life and anime in Tokyo. The natural splendor of Japan, Fuji and Asama covered in snow, the snow monkeys in the forest near Nagano, the hot springs every place we stayed, and the gardens such as Kenroku-en in Kanazawa provided plenitude of being.

Kanazawa

After Japan, Will and I trained to New York and Brooklyn to meet up with Joe and see his performance at BAM of the RSC production of Julius Caesar. It was a delight to walk through Greenwich Village and Central park with Will, to see the art in the Metropolitan, including Gertrude Stein, and to visit the Stonewall Bar.  Summer brought trips to Savannah to stay with the Killians at Tybee and a week in September with Joe and Will at the Jasper House. Other trips included several to stay with Starr on Lookout Mountain, and a trip to the Blue Ridge Mts. Asheville and Dillard with Will, meeting up with Karen and Lee at the Dillard House.
2013 took Maggie and Joce to Venice Florida. A trip to their new home was aborted when Joce's fractured ankle refused to heal.

On the home-front in Atlanta, Darryl perfected his apple-walnut, apple-pecan, and pumpkin pie delights. He also enrolled in the ACA (Obama-care). We shall end the year hosting Joe again, after which we shall welcome in 2014 with a week in Savannah at the Connor House.


Joseph Mydell, at home in the Connor House, 2012

Here's to 2014...




Saturday, November 23, 2013

COMET

Will Comet Ison dazzle our December this year?

(Alas, no. The dazzle fizzled as the comet vaporized near the Sun.)


12 Cool Facts about Comet ISON


Comet ISON
Comet ISON on Nov. 16, 2013. Click to embiggen.
Photo by Waldemar Skorupa, via CIOC and spaceweather.com
Over the years we’ve had some pretty amazing comets swing by our planet. I remember the ones I’ve seen myself: HyakutakeHale-BoppHolmesPan-STARRS,McNaught… they were all beautiful and amazing sights.

Phil PlaitPHIL PLAIT
Phil Plait writes Slate’s Bad Astronomy blog and is an astronomer, public speaker, science evangelizer, and author of Death from the Skies! 
Now we have C/2012 S1 (ISON) passing our way, and it’s certainly grabbing attention. It’s brightened substantially in just the past few days, so now’s the time to see it! The pictures people are taking are phenomenal, and there’s plenty of science pouring in as well.
Everyone loves a good picture, of course, but comets are amazing well beyond just their stunning beauty. So I figured I’d take this opportunity to tell you a few things about this comet, a handful of facts to nourish the part of your brain seeking out wonder. Keep these in mind while you’re gawking at the gorgeous pictures.
1) ISON is a n00b.
Some comets are on long, elliptical orbits dropping them in to the inner solar system before sailing them back out to the depths of space. There, they slow, stop, then fall once again back into the warmth and light. Comet Halley, for example, is on a 75-year orbit that takes it out past Neptune.
But some are more extreme. If they get an extra kick on their way in — perhaps from a collision, or a boost by a planet’s gravity — their elliptical orbit gets turned into an open-ended hyperbola: they have more than enough energy to leave the solar system forever. Once they’re gone, they’re gone.
ISON is a hyperbolic comet, which means this is it: These next few weeks are our only chance to see it. After it swings back out, it ain’t coming back. This is likely its first tour of the inner solar system as well, which is why scientists are so excited about it; we’re seeing a pristine comet, billions of years old, a relic of the ancient solar system. It’s a time capsule, letting us study what conditions were like when the Sun and planets were young.
2) ISON is a sun-diver.

ISON orbit by the Sun
The orbit of ISON passes very close to the Sun. This diagram shows what NASA/ESA's SOHO satellite will see; the various circles are the different fields of view of SOHO's cameras.
Photo by NASA / ESA / SOHO
The orbit of ISON takes it very, very close to the Sun’s surface. Next week, on Nov. 28, it will skim a mere 1.1 million kilometers (about 700,000 miles) above the Sun’s surface. Given that the Sun is 1.4 million km across, that’s a mighty close shave! The heat it feels will be intense, and it may not survive the encounter (see #10 below).
3) When it passes the Sun, it will be moving at 360 kilometers per second.
Imagine dropping a rock. The higher you drop it, the longer the Earth’s gravity has to pull on it, and the faster it’ll be moving when it hits the ground.
The fastest a rock can hit the Earth is if you drop it from infinitely far away. When it hits it’ll be moving at escape velocity — and the physics of dropping it is reversible, so if you throw a rock at escape velocity it will continue on forever (hence the term "escape velocity").

Comet SWAN
Comet SWAN (left) on a death dive into the Sun in 2012.
Photo by NASA / ESA / SOHO
The same is true for a comet rounding (or, in some cases, impacting) the Sun. Since ISON is falling from essentially infinitely far away, when it goes around the Sun it’ll be moving at the Sun’s escape velocity at that distance, or just about 360 km/sec (225 miles/sec). How fast is that? Well, it's hundreds of times faster than rifle bullet, for example, and over 1500 times faster than a commercial jet — at that speed, the comet would cross the continental United States in about 15 seconds.
In fact, it will be moving at 0.1% the speed of light! That’s far faster than any human-made space probe has ever traveled. And the only propulsion it uses is gravity.
[CORRECTION (Nov. 22, 2013 at 16:15 UTC): I made an error in the calculation for this section, using the escape velocity for the Sun's surface, and not for the distance ISON will be from the Sun's center. This deserves a longer explanation, so I wrote a follow-up post about it, and simply corrected the problem here.]
4) The solid part of ISON is only about two kilometers across.

comet Hartley 2
The nucleus of comet Hartley 2, seen up close during a flyby of the EPOXI spacecraft in 2010. You can see jets of material (ice turning into gas) from pockets on the surface.
Photo by NASA / JPL-Caltech / UMD
Comets are actually lumps of rock, gravel, and ice mixed together. This solid part of the comet is called the nucleus, and some are huge; Hale-Bopp had a nucleus about 30 km (20 miles) across.
ISON, though, is tiny, only about 2 km (1.2 miles) across. Heck, plop it down in the middle of the Rocky Mountains and you’d hardly notice it! The size has been estimated using images taken from the Hubble Space Telescope, which in reality only give us an upper limit. It might even be smaller.
Still, that’s enough to make the comet visible to the naked eye even from a distance of a hundred million kilometers! How can that be? Why, it’s because…
5) The coma is well over 100,000 km in size.

ISON and Earth
A very rough comparison of the physical size of ISON’s coma and the Earth. On this scale, the solid nucleus of ISON would be about the size of a bacterium.
Comet photo by Damian Peach
When you look at a picture of ISON (or any comet), you’re not seeing the nucleus. You’re seeing the gas surrounding it that was once frozen beneath the surface. When the comet gets near the Sun this ice warms and turns directly into a gas. It escapes the weak gravity of the nucleus, forming the fuzzy coma around it.
Since the coma isn’t solid, it doesn’t have a sharp edge. But on Nov. 15, the coma for ISON was estimated to appear about 3 arcminutes across (that’s a size on the sky; the Moon is 30 arcminutes across for comparison). Since ISON was about 140 million km (90 million miles) from Earth at the time, that would put the coma at a size of about 120,000 km (80,000 miles). That’s ten times the diameter of Earth!
6) The tail of the comet is (at least) 8 million kilometers long.

ISON
Comet ISON on Nov. 12, 2013.
Photo by Michael Jäger
Once the gas (and ejected dust) in the coma is out in space, it can be affected by both the solar wind and the pressure of sunlight. It streams away, forming one or more long tails. Like the coma, this is extremely rarefied gas, so it doesn’t really have an edge, but the tail of ISON has been measured to be at least 8 million km (5 million miles) long. That’s 20 times the distance of the Moon from the Earth.
7) The tail is essentially a vacuum.
Weirdly, despite being bright and obvious, a comet’s tail is incredibly ethereal. The density of atoms in a typical tail can run up to about 50,000 atoms per cubic centimeter. Sound like a lot? In a cubic centimeter of air at sea level, there are 1019(10,000,000,000,000,000,000) atoms/molecules per cc! Compared to the air we breathe, a comet’s tail is a hard vacuum. It’s only bright because it’s so big, and reflects sunlight.
8) The total mass of the comet is about 2 - 3 billion tons.
Ice isn’t terribly dense; it floats on water! If ISON is a typical mix of ice and rock, it has a density of about 600 kg per cubic meters. Assuming it’s a sphere two km across, that gives it a mass of roughly 2 - 3 billion tons. That may sounds like a lot, but remember, ice is far less dense than rock. A small rocky mountain would be far more massive.
[Comet ISON over a 70-minute period on Nov. 14, 2013, taken by Bruce Gary].
9) ISON is shrinking.
Measurements of how much water ice is leaving the comet’s surface indicate it’s losing about 1029 molecules of water every second (bearing in mind this goes up and down all the time). Doing the math, I get that this is about three tons per second — enough to fill an Olympic pool in about ten minutes. That’s a fair amount, but given the total mass of the comet, it would take about 25 years at this rate for the comet to totally disappear. Since it’s only shedding mass for the few weeks it’s near the Sun, it’s got mass to spare. Thanks to @SungrazingComets and the Comet ISON Observing Campaign for their help with this.
10) ISON may disintegrate

ISON and wings
ISON sprouts "wings"! The arcs above and below the nucleus are common when pieces of a comet break off. In this case, though, no fragments were seen.
Photo by Wendelstein Observatory of the LMU / MPS
That doesn’t mean it’s safe, though! Some comets aren’t terribly solid; the ice is what holds them together. As they near the Sun and the ice starts to go away, big chunks can break off (called “calving”). In some cases the comet can disintegrate spectacularly. Even if they survive their plunge down to the Sun, some comets get so close they evaporate; we’ve seen that happen too!
It’s not clear if ISON will survive its close shave with the Sun. As of right now it seems to be OK, but who knows what the next few days will bring.
11) ISON won’t hit the Earth.

shutterstock_impactearth_no
Nope.
Photo by Shutterstock / buradaki (modified by Phil Plait)
Whenever there’s a bright comet (or near pass of an asteroid), conspiracy buffs start thinking it’ll hit us. Don’t worry about ISON. The closest it will get is on Dec. 26, 2013, when it will be about 60 million km (40 million miles) from Earth. That’s 150 times farther away than the Moon.
12) You can see it for yourself, and it may become visible in broad daylight.

Pan-STARRS
Comet Pan-STARRS (between the trees, under the jet contrail) shortly after sunset on Mar. 19, 2013.
Photo by Phil Plait
Right now, ISON is bright enough to see naked eye, and easily with binoculars. It’s jumped in brightness twice just in the past week or so! As it gets near the Sun it’ll get brighter, but harder to find because, duh, it’s getting near the Sun.
However, sometimes comets like this get incredibly bright when they are close to the Sun. In 2007, I saw comet McNaught at noon. Yes, noon. It was difficult, and I had to be very careful; you don’t want to wind up looking right at the Sun, especially in binoculars, unless boiled eyeballs is something you want. Seriously, don’t just scan around with binoculars looking for the comet, because it’s very dangerous and can blind you.
There’s no way to know right now, but it’s possible that ISON will be visible in broad daylight to the naked eye for the short time it’s near the Sun. It could be possible to see it during the day if you position yourself so that the Sun is blocked behind a tree, or the edge of a house. It depends on the exact position of the comet relative to the Sun, of course.
Again, doing this is difficult and you shouldn't attempt it unless you know what you’re doing. I’ll note that in general, glancing briefly at the Sun won’t hurt a normal eye with an undilated pupil, but it’s not a good idea to do it too much, and it’s more dangerous for kids (their lenses let through more UV light than adult eyes).
Your better bet is to wait a few more days. Once ISON rounds the Sun, it’ll be visible in the west after sunset for a few weeks for those of us in the northern hemisphere, so watching it will be far easier (right now you have to get up at about 5:00 a.m., before sunrise, to see it). Here’s a finder chart (Sky and Telescope has another as well) that’ll help you spot it; planetarium software for mobile devices are great too (I like Sky Safari, but there are many to choose from). You can find plenty more finder charts online. I’ll note it’ll fade with time, but around Dec. 20 or so it should be out of the Sun’s glare, and (hopefully) easily visible with binoculars. [UPDATE (Nov. 22, 2013 at 16:15 UTC): I'll note that once it passes the Sun, the comet will still be visible in the east before sunrise in the morning as well as in the west after sunset in the evening. I explain this in a follow-up post.]
Seeing a good comet is a wonderful experience, and ISON gives us a chance to experience something that will only come around once, quite literally. This isn’t science fiction, or something out of a movie: This object exists, and it’s just one small part of a much grander universe that’s out there. I hope you can take a moment to drink that in.